Add A trading section?

[kag]

I don't know if its just me but theres a lot of trades people want to do but theres no real section for it so I think we should make a trading section for just all around gaming accounts / social media accounts or we could add a trading section to the minecraft accounts it might just be me if you disagree please state why.



or a trading tag

 

[jxhdvn]

A section for that isn't really needed - I figure a prefix would be fine. "Buying / Selling / Trading"

 

[kag]

A trading section is also part of the idea and Justis don't mean to call you out but could you possibly explain why you disagree?

 

[Justis]

If we create a "trading section" for this, we'd need to create a trading section for every product. Superfluous. Bloated.
Or have social media/gaming accounts be special exceptions, and I hate exceptions. It makes the site less intuitive to use, and organization an absolute mess.
I'd say that a "trading" tag would be more suitable, but I would also rather remove such a tag after the filtering capabilities I want implemented into our sections is made reality. Because "trading" is essentially both buying and selling, and splitting them up would only serve to make relevant thread location more difficult. I'd rather the threads filter into both buying and selling, without the visual aesthetic burden of two tags.

 

[jxhdvn]

I'd say that a "trading" tag would be more suitable

A section for that isn't really needed - I figure a prefix would be fine. "Buying / Selling / Trading"

USETHEAGREEBUTTON.COM XDDDDDD

 

[Justis]

USETHEAGREEBUTTON.COM XDDDDDD

1. I didn't make a comment until I was tagged and specifically requested to provide my reasoning.
2. I stated far more than "I'd say that a "trading" tag would be more suitable", because, if you kept reading, you'd see that I don't want a trading tag. I mentioned it only to explain why I don't believe that it is a suitable solution either. Hence my not agreeing with your post.
3. If you thought my statement was the same as yours, reporting it would have been far more appropriate than making an additional useless comment on the suggestion thread.
Private messaging me with a link to the site or including it as an additional statement along with something constructive would have been the most appropriate way to link it if you believed I was unaware of how to use the agree button.

Thanks though.

 

[jxhdvn]

1. I didn't make a comment until I was tagged and specifically requested to provide my reasoning.
2. I stated far more than "I'd say that a "trading" tag would be more suitable", because, if you kept reading, you'd see that I don't want a trading tag. I mentioned it only to explain why I don't believe that it is a suitable solution either. Hence my not agreeing with your post.
3. If you thought my statement was the same as yours, reporting it would have been far more appropriate than making an additional useless comment on the suggestion thread.
Private messaging me with a link to the site or including it as an additional statement along with something constructive would have been the most appropriate way to link it if you believed I was unaware of how to use the agree button.

Thanks though.

it was supposed to be a shitty joke but thanks for the long explanation

 

[Mick]

If we create a "trading section" for this, we'd need to create a trading section for every product. Superfluous. Bloated.
Or have social media/gaming accounts be special exceptions, and I hate exceptions. It makes the site less intuitive to use, and organization an absolute mess.
I'd say that a "trading" tag would be more suitable, but I would also rather remove such a tag after the filtering capabilities I want implemented into our sections is made reality. Because "trading" is essentially both buying and selling, and splitting them up would only serve to make relevant thread location more difficult. I'd rather the threads filter into both buying and selling, without the visual aesthetic burden of two tags.

This.

However, I don't want for us to add in any more prefix until we make a definitive decision about how prefixes should work on the site and until we're able to make them intuitive, useful, and consistent across the different forums.

Denied, thanks for the suggestion.