Community SMP - Vanilla or Economy?

Status

Mick

BuiltByBit Owner
Management
Feedback score
28
Posts
6,413
Reactions
7,704
Resources
0
Hello again,

Yesterday (technically today) I made a suggestion thread about creating a new community SMP server for MC-Market users to play on for the next few weeks and months. That suggestion thread received a massively positive response, far more excited for a community server than I was expecting which is always good to see.

Now that we're certain that we all want a community server, the next step is for us to now decide what sort of server we want to make it. In the previous suggestion, I briefly mentioned either a vanilla server or economy, but I'll go more into depth about each option and leave it up to a community vote to see what you would prefer.

OPTION 1 -- VANILLA
This is the more simple option and would likely be faster for us to be able to release to the public. A vanilla server would have no functionality or features that change gameplay, and the only plugins on the server will be:
  • An anticheat plugin to stop those pesky hackers
  • A fancy anti-xray plugin to stop those pesky xrayers
  • A chest protection plugin such as Lockette for players to prevent other people from opening chests that they own
  • A land protection plugin such as GriefPrevention to stop people fricking with your beautiful house
  • The username plugin we used on the UHC event, which allows us to set your in-game username to be identical to your on-site username.
Other than those plugins, we would not add any other features to the server, it would simply be a fun hard mode 1.15.2 server without even giving access to /tpa or /home or /warp or /spawn. Very vanilla.

OPTION 2 -- ECONOMY
Many of us on this website are veteran Minecraft players who have beat the game fully dozens of times by now, and completely vanilla might not stay fun for very long. This option is really focused on farming and making a profit through an economy-driven server and more functionality which should theoretically make the game have more content to achieve and more to do. This option would contain all of the plugins of the vanilla server, along with:
  • Justis' AutoEconomy plugin which balances the price of items based on the server’s supply and demand while always ensuring that items derived from other items have their prices proportionately derived from them. By matching market worth with our real-time gameplay and actual economic development, we properly represent the community’s collective progress, encourage full use of the world and we avoid the economic downfall of many servers where prices are static and abuse of the most easily farmed item(s) is unavoidable. The system is far more complex than I am able to explain it in a short paragraph, so I'd recommend that you take a gander at Justis' appraisal thread he made for the plugin here.
  • Chest shops allowing for players to create their own shops to sell items for money
  • Essentials, with players being given many of the standard commands such as /home, /tpa, etc. No /fly. Maybe we could allow people to /setwarp for a price?
  • Possibly mcMMO to allow people to grind for levels if that's the sort of thing that interests them. If we have mcMMO and an economy perhaps we could provide rewards at the end of the first month to the player who has the highest mcmmo level and most money? That could be fun and interesting.
  • A whole bunch of smaller miscellaneous plugins that might slightly liven things up a bit, such as ChatReaction giving the first person to say a certain phrase $x.

Regardless of which server we make, we will be opening it to any MC-Market users who are Premium or above and probably for around 2 months. After that point, we will offer the world download to anyone who wants it to continue playing.

If anyone has any more specific ideas of what to add I'd love to hear them, and I can keep updating this original post with more ideas as more people come up with things to add. Since this is a community server I'd really like for us to be able to come up with a server that will be fun for as many people to play as possible.

I look forward to hearing your input and making this server with you all :)

Mick
 
Type
Suggestion
Status
Implemented
PebbleHost
High performance, consistent uptime and fast support. Minecraft hosting that just works.

Saaami

今日はかわいいですね:D
Supreme
Feedback score
3
Posts
355
Reactions
123
Resources
0
first

and I'd say the economy makes it more of a grind
 

Cole

Developer
Supreme
Feedback score
19
Posts
943
Reactions
477
Resources
0
Economy, I want to make Tesco in Minecraft
 

Lotus

Professional Flower
Premium
Feedback score
23
Posts
497
Reactions
370
Resources
0
Thoughts on a world generator plugin as part of economy? Such as EpicWorldGenerator.
 

Mick

BuiltByBit Owner
Management
Feedback score
28
Posts
6,413
Reactions
7,704
Resources
0
Thoughts on a world generator plugin as part of economy? Such as EpicWorldGenerator.
I was asking about that earlier in chat and out of the 5+ people that replied, nobody liked the idea of using EpicWorldGenerator. If anyone does want EWG then we can look into that more perhaps, but otherwise it seems like people would prefer the vanilla world generation.
 

Turtle

turtle#1989
Supreme
Feedback score
17
Posts
751
Reactions
419
Resources
0
please no mcmmo
 

Rock

A Plethora
Supreme
Feedback score
3
Posts
128
Reactions
33
Resources
0
I'd like EWG. To put in my 2 thoughts
 

nether1

I like turtles
Supreme
Feedback score
28
Posts
591
Reactions
271
Resources
0
If you guys are gonna do this on 1.15. Don't use EWG because of lag from both plugin and server version.
 
Last edited:

Mason.

:)
Supreme
Feedback score
36
Posts
1,032
Reactions
439
Resources
0
Definitely economy. Some great ideas overall, would love to see this happen :)[DOUBLEPOST=1585925877][/DOUBLEPOST]
probably for around 2 months.
Keep it dude, this would be awesome to have around for the long haul. We could have map wipes every 2 months with a grace period of 1 week for updates and unique changes, also to have a chance to download your progress if you really like that map.

Idk, I bet people would love to have this around, I know I would.
 
Last edited:

joerock777

Resume Maker | Discord & Xenforo Setup Specialist
Supreme
Feedback score
22
Posts
547
Reactions
249
Resources
0
I wouldn’t mind it as well. If we have vanilla, I’m going to try and get the dragon egg and sell it here
 

utaninja

( ̄^ ̄ )ゞ
Supreme
Feedback score
36
Posts
1,360
Reactions
940
Resources
0
Would MCM compensate Justis for the provided plugin or time it takes to develop it?
 

BOOP

Director of Ops @ Zelphra
Supreme
Feedback score
23
Posts
2,384
Reactions
1,095
Resources
0
Regardless of which server we make, we will be opening it to any MC-Market users who are Premium or above and probably for around 2 months. After that point, we will offer the world download to anyone who wants it to continue playing.
bruh this is gonna end up like the last server, with it averaging 2 players at a time. Open it up to every user that has been on for at least 6 Months, and has X messages or something. Because making it premium only means it's gonna be hella inactive
 

Red

Chromatic Polymath
Supreme
Feedback score
34
Posts
1,251
Reactions
632
Resources
0
Mine’s the unpopular opinion here, but I’d far prefer Vanilla over Economy. See, I’ve been playing combat-based minigames in Minecraft for most of my time playing the game (of which the last few years have been really inactive for me). I haven’t played a survival world since version 1.5, and that was in 2012, I believe. Because most PVP’ers prefer 1.8 and below, I’ve barely even looked at the new features added, much less tired them out. Playing a Vanilla world would be pretty exciting for me, since so much would be brand new.

That said, obviously I’m not going to be the only one playing on this server, so I’m interested in seeing what the community wants as a whole.
 

tommy099431

Feedback score
2
Posts
208
Reactions
45
Resources
0
if done right, both could be huge successes, just gotta not overdue it like a lot of these servers do. Minecraft servers from 2014/15 and older were done right, simple and some of the best Minecraft days I had have it be economy, vanilla, towny etc, now its so confusing and everyone makes a server because they can.
I would love to make a server, but haven't played in years and only want to do it, if I can make it like the good old days.
 
Last edited:

Mick

BuiltByBit Owner
Management
Feedback score
28
Posts
6,413
Reactions
7,704
Resources
0
If you guys are gonna do this on 1.15. Don't use EWG because of lag from both plugin and server version.
This makes a lot of sense. I know how resource-intensive 1.15 can be, and using EWG certainly wouldn't help that. We'll stick with vanilla for this server and see how we go with that.

Keep it dude, this would be awesome to have around for the long haul. We could have map wipes every 2 months with a grace period of 1 week for updates and unique changes, also to have a chance to download your progress if you really like that map.

Idk, I bet people would love to have this around, I know I would.
We'll see how this server goes now, and if there are still a bunch of people playing at the end of the 2 months we can look into creating a new one with improvements, but in all honesty I don't see this as being too likely.

I wouldn’t mind it as well. If we have vanilla, I’m going to try and get the dragon egg and sell it here
Pretty sure that you can re-spawn the dragon in 1.15 and you can buy dragon eggs from the server shop, so I'm not too sure how successful your plan will be, but it's a cool thought!

What would you prefer?

bruh this is gonna end up like the last server, with it averaging 2 players at a time. Open it up to every user that has been on for at least 6 Months, and has X messages or something. Because making it premium only means it's gonna be hella inactive
I disagree that opening this up to all users who meet that requirement would result in much more activity. Ultimately our server isn't going to be the most amazing setup for people to play on, but our community is going to enjoy it because you get to play with other MC-Market people. Someone without Premium (and who is unwilling to purchase it to play) likely isn't going to stick around long enough on the server to make any noticeable difference to the playerbase. Essentially putting a $10 price on being able to join means that the only people who are going to play are people who have something to lose if they hack on the server and get banned from it. I don't think that there are many active members of our community with a decent amount of posts and who have been here for 6 months without Premium anyway.

if done right, both could be huge successes, just gotta not overdue it like a lot of these servers do. Minecraft servers from 2014/15 and older were done right, simple and some of the best Minecraft days I had have it be economy, vanilla, towny etc, now its so confusing and everyone makes a server because they can.
Yeah definitely, I get where you're coming from. Right now the plugins that we have are as follows:

upload_2020-4-4_0-31-55.png


Does anyone have any other recommendations for what could be added to make the server more interesting to play on without being too packed full of features in a way that might ruin the fun of it? The only other plugins I know I want to add are Justis' AutoEconomy and an anti-xray.
 

Attachments

  • upload_2020-4-4_0-31-55.png
    upload_2020-4-4_0-31-55.png
    31.2 KB · Views: 206

joerock777

Resume Maker | Discord & Xenforo Setup Specialist
Supreme
Feedback score
22
Posts
547
Reactions
249
Resources
0
This makes a lot of sense. I know how resource-intensive 1.15 can be, and using EWG certainly wouldn't help that. We'll stick with vanilla for this server and see how we go with that.


We'll see how this server goes now, and if there are still a bunch of people playing at the end of the 2 months we can look into creating a new one with improvements, but in all honesty I don't see this as being too likely.


Pretty sure that you can re-spawn the dragon in 1.15 and you can buy dragon eggs from the server shop, so I'm not too sure how successful your plan will be, but it's a cool thought!


What would you prefer?


I disagree that opening this up to all users who meet that requirement would result in much more activity. Ultimately our server isn't going to be the most amazing setup for people to play on, but our community is going to enjoy it because you get to play with other MC-Market people. Someone without Premium (and who is unwilling to purchase it to play) likely isn't going to stick around long enough on the server to make any noticeable difference to the playerbase. Essentially putting a $10 price on being able to join means that the only people who are going to play are people who have something to lose if they hack on the server and get banned from it. I don't think that there are many active members of our community with a decent amount of posts and who have been here for 6 months without Premium anyway.


Yeah definitely, I get where you're coming from. Right now the plugins that we have are as follows:

View attachment 328163

Does anyone have any other recommendations for what could be added to make the server more interesting to play on without being too packed full of features in a way that might ruin the fun of it? The only other plugins I know I want to add are Justis' AutoEconomy and an anti-xray.
Il sell an elytra then
 
Status
Top