Constructive Criticism Acid-Islands

[Jamezyy]

Hello, I own a fairly new server called Acid-Islands.

The server is a server where you create a island and make your way up to the big islands! Of course, the water is acid. So tell me what you think is good and bad. Thank you.

IP: acid-islands.com

 

[Solistica]

- Spawn room needs some creativity added to it. Just a white wool box.
- /Vote brings up no links
- /? let's you see plugins, as well as /bukkit:?
- The Island part is cool, but my island was created in an Ice Biome, so moving around to other Islands was not difficult.
- On your buycraft it says you can contact [email protected] , but that email doesn't actually exist.
- ClearLagg is generic setup except it was changed to [AcidLagg]
- No Spawn
- Cannot do /c for Challenges even though it says to on the first sign you see when you login.
- No Forums? Where will your players hang out?

Theme is a cool idea, I personally haven't see it before but I have a feeling it's out there a lot already.
Just needs more time put into it. You'll get there!

 

[Jamezyy]

- Spawn room needs some creativity added to it. Just a white wool box.
- /Vote brings up no links
- /? let's you see plugins, as well as /bukkit:?
- The Island part is cool, but my island was created in an Ice Biome, so moving around to other Islands was not difficult.
- On your buycraft it says you can contact [email protected] , but that email doesn't actually exist.
- ClearLagg is generic setup except it was changed to [AcidLagg]
- No Spawn
- Cannot do /c for Challenges even though it says to on the first sign you see when you login.
- No Forums? Where will your players hang out?

Theme is a cool idea, I personally haven't see it before but I have a feeling it's out there a lot already.
Just needs more time put into it. You'll get there!

Yep thank you, I am ordering a custom built spawn, fixed ranks and made the chat better.

 

[Kynetic]

You lack the appeal to generate any large playerbase through your gamemode. Unless you have a big youtube name behind you doing a LP of this, I don't think this can go anywhere.

 

[Jamezyy]

You lack the appeal to generate any large playerbase through your gamemode. Unless you have a big youtube name behind you doing a LP of this, I don't think this can go anywhere.

I would just like to get around 10 players a day. (playerbase)[DOUBLEPOST=1423649740,1423649706][/DOUBLEPOST]+ We have not advertised yet. On any websites.

 

[Kynetic]

Yes but that's not the point. Skyblock is well known and servers have put interesting spins on them already. These servers also have custom plugins to improve user experience. I'm guessing you're using like three public plugins. The real question comes down to, why would anyone play this over skyblock? And don't say because its new because its not, its a public plugin. So the fact that literally no popular server runs this gamemode should be clue enough to avoid it entirely.

 

[Jamezyy]

Yes but that's not the point. Skyblock is well known and servers have put interesting spins on them already. These servers also have custom plugins to improve user experience. I'm guessing you're using like three public plugins. The real question comes down to, why would anyone play this over skyblock? And don't say because its new because its not, its a public plugin. So the fact that literally no popular server runs this gamemode should be clue enough to avoid it entirely.

Nah. See it grow.