Feedback on first ever product mockup designs

[Lexxonist]

So I made two mock-up designs for canvases and I'm wanting an opinion on how they look. This was my first time designing mock-ups for products.

What I've currently done is sent two images to 3 people, one image was a mockup and the other was a regular image and I asked them which they thought was real and which one was fake or if if they thought both were real or fake (fake is referring to the mockup). In all 3 guesses, they thought that the mockup was real and the real image was fake.

Soooo what do you all think, are they realistic? (Both of these are mock-ups).

1.

2.

 

[sentosa]

The ones that say "Mockup by Lexxionist" look fake. The others look real.

 

[Lexxonist]

The ones that say "Mockup by Lexxionist" look fake. The others look real.

Thanks,

I guess that just supports the idea that if you know something is fake (by the text in this case), it'll look fake

 

[sentosa]

Thanks,

I guess that just supports the idea that if you know something is fake (by the text in this case), it'll look fake

No, it just straight up looks fake. I knew it was fake the moment I looked at it.

 

[Lexxonist]

No, it just straight up looks fake. I knew it was fake the moment I looked at it.

it's no different to the others though

 

[Rhos]

I think he means the second mockup where it's reflected in the table, it's too bright - it just looks like one image overlaid on another. The first one is really great though.

 

[Lexxonist]

I think he means the second mockup where it's reflected in the table, it's too bright - it just looks like one image overlaid on another. The first one is really great though.

Ah, thanks