Feedback on logo design

[Masons Monarch]

Hi, this is like the 3rd time I've made one of the but yall are helpful so here we go.

Please vote which you like better.
Top left: 1
Top Right: 2
Bottom left: 3
Bottom right: 4

 

[HeyItsSkay]

1 Is my fav but they're all good. In order from best to not best I would say 1, 4, 2, 3

 

[Masons Monarch]

1 Is my fav but they're all good. In order from best to not best I would say 1, 4, 2, 3

Thank you.

 

[Demeng]

I think 4, the color is similar to the actual trident in MC so it makes more sense to me. And the blue background can be water I guess

 

[oretheus]

my version is better tbh https://gyazo.com/5df0d8e23fa99c0c6223f333edd1717d

 

[Masons Monarch]

my version is better tbh https://gyazo.com/5df0d8e23fa99c0c6223f333edd1717d

Bruh why are you putting such a masterpiece on my thread

 

[Red]

Bottom left is by far the best in my book. This is partially because I feel that red and white is the greatest, most underrated color combination in the world, but it goes deeper than that. In logo design, you should strive to say something about your business with as minimal noise as possible (within reason). The gradients on the top don’t imply the discreetness you see in Minecraft blocks, but the solid color squares on the bottom do. Beyond that, the bottom right is blue and black, which is usually frowned upon. If you wanted to use that one, I’d make the blues a few shades darker each.

Source: learned basic logo design in a high school class in 2013

 

[Masons Monarch]

Bottom left is by far the best in my book. This is partially because I feel that red and white is the greatest, most underrated color combination in the world, but it goes deeper than that. In logo design, you should strive to say something about your business with as minimal noise as possible (within reason). The gradients on the top don’t imply the discreetness you see in Minecraft blocks, but the solid color squares on the bottom do. Beyond that, the bottom right is blue and black, which is usually frowned upon. If you wanted to use that one, I’d make the blues a few shades darker each.

Source: learned basic logo design in a high school class in 2013

Thank you for the helpful feedback. I am currently debating on which to use. I think I am definitely not going to use either of the blue ones but you make a good point about using the one that is clearly more minecraft oriented.

 

[Masons Monarch]

In my opinion 1 looks the best.

Thank you.

 

[Masons Monarch]

Here is the final product, ty everyone