Let us immediately snipe banned users usernames

PebbleHost
High performance, consistent uptime and fast support. Minecraft hosting that just works.

Blockhead

Professional procrastinator
Supreme
Feedback score
1
Posts
67
Reactions
15
Resources
0
That makes no sense at all because people can appeal a ban and it would be unfair to them to have to change the username just because someone took it (if they got unbanned).

Note: I'm talking under the assumption that "snipe usernames" means being able to rename yourself to that username. Not sure that's what it is.
 

Blockhead

Professional procrastinator
Supreme
Feedback score
1
Posts
67
Reactions
15
Resources
0
I can half agree with this, but what if a person was ban evading? Shouldn't we already know that ban will not be appealed?
Hmmm... now that you mention it, that could work in theory, however I'm not sure how what OP wants or you suggested could be done with XenForo. It would most likely require a custom addon of sorts, although I can't afford it so I wouldn't know.
 
Last edited:

Ted

B.Sc in Information Technology
Supreme
Feedback score
56
Posts
1,406
Reactions
803
Resources
0
sFRmBxO.png
 

Ted

B.Sc in Information Technology
Supreme
Feedback score
56
Posts
1,406
Reactions
803
Resources
0
It would be a nightmare for a lot of reasons. Take Xiri for example, someone instantly running around with a 100+ rep? or a user justly banned and their name getting moved to another user who impersonates them so quickly. Kappa
 

Geek

Mom of BBB
Support
Feedback score
11
Posts
897
Reactions
267
Resources
1
I can half agree with this, but what if a person was ban evading? Shouldn't we already know that ban will not be appealed?[DOUBLEPOST=1612283597][/DOUBLEPOST]
You can actually request a name change within a ticket and they'll get it sorted out with you. So there's literally no point to this. And on top of this, only Premium members are able to change their names.
Just to clarify, you can always able to appeal bans, even ban evading bans. Just because you were banned for ban evasion doesn't immediately reject your chances of appealing. Supreme users can submit username request changes (take other user's name), but all upgraded members can change their names if its not taken.

I personally am against this for reasons that Shark said, but also because almost always we are unable to solve a ticket within the 24 hours or so after the user is banned which is when that name would be taken, so it would be illogical for such a change to take place.
 

Exsistory

Supreme
Feedback score
4
Posts
136
Reactions
39
Resources
4
This would be a interesting concept, but as people have mentioned the user having to get a new user name would be unfair especially if they do get unbanned.

maybe have a system that would close accounts that are banned longer than 3 years and just rename then to “banned-account#0001” and open up the ign, the wait period would be perfect for the banned user to appeal or wait for their ban to expire (if it does)
 

Justis

Community Member
Management
Feedback score
61
Posts
2,117
Reactions
2,414
Resources
0
Whether they are banned or not, we have the requirement of them having not been active for at least 6 months so that nobody is effectively impersonating someone else by taking their name.

Why would you want to risk having the reputation of someone who was just banned associated with you anyway?
Wouldn’t you want a chance for the heat on that name to cool off before the name becomes available for repossession?
 
Top