Make Appraisal section semi private

[katana2]

If u dont understand i want to limit People who can reply in Appraisal section making it look better and realistic. People takes advantage of the Fake Appraisals and post semi accounts into OG section because someone else joking says "X" price * cough cough ign cough cough *

Imo users that should have the right to reply/appraise
Fortnite: Desert Scooby and Fanta
Domain: Croc and Walmart (i dunno More)
Minecraft: Choo blob kag and puzeh

 

[JayMC]

Are you saying only allow a very specific group to reply (like just the people you mentioned)? Or are you saying there should be requirements kind of like to have access to the private OG section?

 

[jxhdvn]

The point of appraisals is to give your take on what an account's value is. Just because people don't have the same view as you doesn't mean you should strip them of their view.

Not to mention.. Why those people? Not even the best at what they're doing, except Choo. You should put actual people like Glove who know accounts like that

 

[Ally]

Not much time is wasted if an appraisal is downright wrong.

Also, the reason forum sections get restricted are because of scams. You're not going to be scammed if you get a bad appraisal. In addition to this, social reputation goes a long way with appraisals (people who have historically appraised incorrectly will tend to have a worse social rep than those who appraise well). Additionally, appraisals are largely subjective, being affected by buyers, sellers, time of year, inflation, whatever. So it could well change.

 

[mai]

If u dont understand i want to limit People who can reply in Appraisal section making it look better and realistic. People takes advantage of the Fake Appraisals and post semi accounts into OG section because someone else joking says "X" price * cough cough ign cough cough *

Imo users that should have the right to reply/appraise
Fortnite: Desert Scooby and Fanta
Domain: Croc and Walmart (i dunno More)
Minecraft: Choo blob kag and puzeh

I mean, I see what you mean and it makes sense but it doesnt stop the fake appraising cause Choo could just as easily false appraise (not that he would, but its still a possibility).
Also, what if the users listed were to be banned, disable their accounts or whatnot. Then there would be no use for the section being as all the people allowed to appraise there would be unable to post.
Another thing is that if someone is able to ask for an appraisal in the thread they can post in it aswell (unless someone finds a way to make it so they can only ask for appraisals and can say nothing else), essentially ruining the idea.

 

[katana2]

Are you saying only allow a very specific group to reply (like just the people you mentioned)?

Yes

Or are you saying there should be requirements kind of like to have access to the private OG section?

No

The point of appraisals is to give your take on what an account's value is. Just because people don't have the same view as you doesn't mean you should strip them of their view.

The problem isn't that that's Their "opPinIOn" the problem Is that they joke about prices and new users that doesn't know thinks they're real
Examples:
https://www.mc-market.org/threads/422480/#post-3496381
https://www.mc-market.org/threads/420459/#post-3485035
I dont have More atm but he appraised StoneSlab for 400 and it took the staff 2 weeks to move it

 

[jxhdvn]

Yes

No


The problem isn't that that's Their "opPinIOn" the problem Is that they joke about prices and new users that doesn't know thinks they're real
Examples:
https://www.mc-market.org/threads/422480/#post-3496381
https://www.mc-market.org/threads/420459/#post-3485035
I dont have More atm but he appraised StoneSlab for 400 and it took the staff 2 weeks to move it

If they're being satirical then that's the users liability. We shouldn't all be restricted just because of some dumbass

 

[JayMC]

Yes

No


The problem isn't that that's Their "opPinIOn" the problem Is that they joke about prices and new users that doesn't know thinks they're real
Examples:
https://www.mc-market.org/threads/422480/#post-3496381
https://www.mc-market.org/threads/420459/#post-3485035
I dont have More atm but he appraised StoneSlab for 400 and it took the staff 2 weeks to move it

I agree there should be some requirements but we should not just limit it to a few specific users.

 

[katana2]

If they're being satirical then that's the users liability. We shouldn't all be restricted just because of some dumbass

I said """IMO" mick or justis can Select them

 

[jxhdvn]

I said """IMO" mick or justis can Select them

You aren't addressing my point. I'm saying just because there are some dumbasses that doesn't mean we should restrict everyone else from speaking. It shouldn't be like the Private OG section, appraisals are opinions and to silence opinions is a big nono

 

[katana2]

I agree there should be some requirements but we should not just limit it to a few specific users.

Pros
1) Good Appraisals
2) Limited replies
3) Makes the section look cleaner
4) Jokes/fase appraisals arent accepted
5) New members know what really Their account Is worth[DOUBLEPOST=1546921629][/DOUBLEPOST]

silence opinions is a big nono

Opinions of clowns?

 

[jxhdvn]

Pros
1) Good Appraisals
2) Limited replies
3) Makes the section look cleaner
4) Jokes/fase appraisals arent accepted
5) New members know what really Their account Is worth[DOUBLEPOST=1546921629][/DOUBLEPOST]
Opinions of clowns?

Everyone has an opinion, if you keep this logic I don't see this thread making it anywhere but the declined suggestions[DOUBLEPOST=1546921928][/DOUBLEPOST]

Pros
1) Good Appraisals
2) Limited replies
3) Makes the section look cleaner
4) Jokes/fase appraisals arent accepted
5) New members know what really Their account Is worth[DOUBLEPOST=1546921629][/DOUBLEPOST]
Opinions of clowns?

1 - That's very subjective

2 - That will lead to way less variety, which is bad if you want appraisals. You want all takes, not just positive takes

3 - The section would still not be clean, due to the abominable amount of threads

4 - Satire in that manner isn't a reason to restrict a majority of users from leaving their intakes. That should be handled all on it's own, there's a reason why we have rules

5 - That's also subjective

 

[katana2]

That will lead to way less variety, which is bad if you want appraisals. You want all takes, not just positive takes

Positive takes? I never said "Every reply Will be good for u!11!!1!" I just meant they're More accurate

 

[jxhdvn]

Positive takes? I never said "Every reply Will be good for u!11!!1!" I just meant they're More accurate

The way you have it set, it would be a very limited amount of users replying to threads. Just because they might be accurate doesn't mean people should be restricted of leaving an intake

 

[Choo]

Guys, stop! This is the bullshittery iNg wants!

 

[Fanta]

If u dont understand i want to limit People who can reply in Appraisal section making it look better and realistic. People takes advantage of the Fake Appraisals and post semi accounts into OG section because someone else joking says "X" price * cough cough ign cough cough *

Imo users that should have the right to reply/appraise
Fortnite: Desert Scooby and Fanta
Domain: Croc and Walmart (i dunno More)
Minecraft: Choo blob kag and puzeh

I like this idea but people wanna try and be funny by putting shit like “Actually this account is worth $5000 in Monopoly money!!1!1!!1”

 

[User]

How about we just have an option to ban people from appraising (kinda like a CS:GO vote kick, if they keep joke appraising or appraising poorly, members can vote to disable their ability to reply to appraisals permanently/temporarily).

 

[pet]

Well I made a thread similar to this but uhm yeah, they won't do it

 

[iNg]

 

[Sore]

Completely disagree. By limiting ability to type there, you not only reduce activity on the forum, but it doesn't allow for new users to make a name for themselves such as myself. If there's only a select few doing appraisals, then if they quit who's gonna do it? I do see why you're saying this but I think everyone should have the right to appraise, who knows, give it a year and there might be new "best appraisers"

I see your point but there's already a system in place to deal with bs, banning them lol

And just noticed that the people who are supporting this idea are the ones who have already had an opportunity to become "experienced appraisers" lmao

EDIT: anyone who has an account that's actually worth something will probably be smart enough to tell if someone's joking or not