Prohibit discussion on Transgenders as it often results in hate speech

[Ghast]

I constantly see the “Transgender people are mentally ill”. It truly sickens me. Are jews mentally sick too? This is honestly pathetic. The belief and acts of one should not define who he is and his mental state. Those are basic principles of humanity.

To solve this active issue, either implant a new rule directly stating at discussion/debate regarding LGBTSQ+ Community is prohibited as it is for religion, or enforce it more than ever.

Drastic changes need to be made.

Bests,
Ghast.

 

[Zorah]

People have opinions, respect it.

Just because they're not saying (well, typing in this instance) what you want to hear doesn't mean they're wrong.

 

[SheepeyDarkness]

How is calling gender dysphoria a mental illness hate speech? If you have PTSD you have a mental illness. If you have gender dysphoria you have a mental illness. If you have PTSD you are mentally ill. If you have gender dysphoria you are mentally ill. Enough said.

Is having PTSD bad? Yes. Is being a person with PTSD make you a bad person or any less of a human being? Not at all.

Nothing wrong with being trans. If trans people need therapy or help, it should be recognized as what it is, a mental disorder/illness/ect.

"Are jews mentally sick too? This is honestly pathetic. The belief and acts of one should not define who he is and his mental state."
One of these is a religion and a belief.
Another one is a psychological issue some may have influenced by genetics.
ADHD is genetic. This is not a belief. This is psychological. You need treatment for this depending on the severity.

Being christian is purely a belief. It is not scientifically hereditary. You can stop being christian. Can you stop having gender dysphoria or adhd? No. You are born with this.

What this is, is unneeded censorship.

 

[Niteburn]

We need a politics thread on MCM, that would be a fun place to hangout lol.[DOUBLEPOST=1555050409][/DOUBLEPOST]Regardless what your opinions are on anything, never take anything over the internet seriously. People say stuff all the time online that they will never say in real life themselves.

 

[SheepeyDarkness]

How did you go from transgender people to jewish people?
That literally makes no sense: “Transgender people are mentally ill”. It truly sickens me. Are jews mentally sick too?". Nobody was ever talking about jews/jewish people.

Also, i'm 90% sure MC-Market is run in the US, so, first amendment:
"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

Unless you're government funded, you have the right to block freedom of speech or censor as a private business.

 

[Ivain]

Prohibiting discussion is not going to prevent hate speech, and there's nothing bad about the discussion itself. Hate speech is already prohibited.

 

[doodle]

Freedom of speech m8

Hate speech isn't real, but I believe that it's in the Terms of Service/Code of Conduct.

 

[Sloth]

Someone can’t handle an opinion that differs from their own.

 

[User]

How did you go from transgender people to jewish people?
That literally makes no sense: “Transgender people are mentally ill”. It truly sickens me. Are jews mentally sick too?". Nobody was ever talking about jews/jewish people.

Also, i'm 90% sure MC-Market is run in the US, so, first amendment:
"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

no, it's run in australia, and mcm rules =/= law[DOUBLEPOST=1555079390][/DOUBLEPOST]

Hate speech isn't real, but I believe that it's in the Terms of Service/Code of Conduct.

i'm gonna have to disagree with you there chief[DOUBLEPOST=1555079419][/DOUBLEPOST]

Prohibiting discussion is not going to prevent hate speech, and there's nothing bad about the discussion itself. Hate speech is already prohibited.

exactly, the discussion should be allowed, no reason to prevent everyone from discussing just because of one ignorant idiot

 

[doodle]

i'm gonna have to disagree with you there chief

I live in America. Hate speech = Freedom of speech.

 

[User]

I live in America. Hate speech = Freedom of speech.

I, too, live in America. Hate speech does not necessarily mean that.

 

[doodle]

I, too, live in America. Hate speech does not necessarily mean that.

It does. There is only one thing you can be arrested for saying in America. Legally, hate speech is not real, and I live by the law. Feel free to open a DM if interested in discussing further, but there's no need to do it here.

 

[User]

It does. There is only one thing you can be arrested for saying in America. Legally, hate speech is not real, and I live by the law. Feel free to open a DM if interested in discussing further, but there's no need to do it here.

nah lol

Unless you're government funded, you have the right to block freedom of speech or censor as a private business.

Yeah, it seems most people don't know about this, for some reason. Only time this isn't allowed is in dictatorship countries, afaik.

 

[doodle]

Yeah, it seems most people don't know about this, for some reason. Only time this isn't allowed is in dictatorship countries, afaik.

"Hate speech" is an umbrella term in America because there is no legal definition of it. Sites can block freedom of speech, that wasn't the discussion lol. I'd be surprised if you could find at least 3 people over the age of 13 who don't know that. Anywho, since you don't wanna discuss it, I'll leave it here.

 

[Ted]

I constantly see the “Transgender people are mentally ill”. It truly sickens me. Are jews mentally sick too? This is honestly pathetic. The belief and acts of one should not define who he is and his mental state. Those are basic principles of humanity.

To solve this active issue, either implant a new rule directly stating at discussion/debate regarding LGBTSQ+ Community is prohibited as it is for religion, or enforce it more than ever.

Drastic changes need to be made.

Bests,
Ghast.

If people don’t like you’re opinion, they can proclaim it as hate speech. Which, is utterly stupid. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions, weather you like it or not. People don’t like change, it’s a fact. Of course there will be people coming out of the closet more expressing how they feel because they feel safer that others are doing it too.

How I procive this;
You’re either born a male, or a female. If you believe strongly you belong to another gender, then that is a mental state of thought. There are those who will define it as an illness, and there are those who won’t. If people are open to change, then be suttle with them. If you attempt to force your opinion into their mind, then that’s where it’s wrong. By banning the act of free speech, which you defined as “hate speech” is also wrong.

 

[Lakia]

I constantly see the “Transgender people are mentally ill”. It truly sickens me. Are jews mentally sick too? This is honestly pathetic. The belief and acts of one should not define who he is and his mental state. Those are basic principles of humanity.

To solve this active issue, either implant a new rule directly stating at discussion/debate regarding LGBTSQ+ Community is prohibited as it is for religion, or enforce it more than ever.

Drastic changes need to be made.

Bests,
Ghast.

As part of the community (the Trans part as well), I would truly appreciate just being able to do business and browse this website without feeling attacked and worthless. Lets make this happen

 

[Sloth]

As part of the community (the Trans part as well), I would truly appreciate just being able to do business and browse this website without feeling attacked and worthless. Lets make this happen

If you feel attacked because someone has an opinion that doesn’t align with yours I recommend possibly getting off the internet