Rate My Server Section

[Aschorren]

Greetings -

A "Rate My Server" section would be a fabulous addition to MC-Market.

With a particularly large community of server owners, it would be a highly productive section to give and receive constructive criticism on aspects of different servers.

The idea is that users would post their servers or Minecraft related projects and different MC-Market community members would check it out and let them know what they did and didn't like.

A section along these lines would inspire collaborative projects, help current creators improve on their own projects, and create a highly productive "think tank" environment where different servers were introduced and discussed.

Please rate this post as AGREE if you would love to see a section like this implemented and leave your thoughts below.

 

[Aschorren]

I disgree owners would brag to much that there server is the best

If you're not going to contribute something sensible to the discussion, please don't contribute at all.

There's literally a section called ACHIEVEMENTS & BRAGGING and this has nothing to do with bragging. Why are you holding my suggestion accountable for something completely irrelevant? [DOUBLEPOST=1465715501][/DOUBLEPOST]

Good idea and I truly agree with how exciting and productive this would be but I can foresee many problems with this idea.

Indeed. It would be exciting and productive.

What problems do you have in mind?

 

[moon10k]

what about the apprials section? why not just add a "server" tag to that?

 

[Aschorren]

what about the apprials section? why not just add a "server" tag to that?

Offering constructive criticism is different than accessing a value.

 

[Chearful]

I hear a couple of warning points coming

 

[Satan]

Not trying to spoil the fun, but um... isn't this what spigotMc is kinda for? Harsh server developers and owners that criticize on point of a professionalism of a server?

A rate my server section on a marketplace community like this would most likely turn out to be a "Appraise my server" section instead and have people asking to buy servers or sell them constantly.

 

[Errota]

100% agree.

 

[Jack]

You could just use the Server Discussion section.
Or the Feedback section to ask for feedback on your server (as you've mentioned 'constructive criticism' multiple times).
Or if you're looking for advice, possibly even the Advice & Assistance section?

As you can see we've already got several sections such a thread could be posted in.
I don't see why we need a specific niche section for this.

 

[Andehh]

Great idea, I like it a lot.
+1.

 

[RebelKnox]

I have a server review service! I stopped doing it since I got bored so this would be a great addition XD

 

[Mick]

I think that Jack summed it up pretty much perfectly here.

You could just use the Server Discussion section.
Or the Feedback section to ask for feedback on your server (as you've mentioned 'constructive criticism' multiple times).
Or if you're looking for advice, possibly even the Advice & Assistance section?

As you can see we've already got several sections such a thread could be posted in.
I don't see why we need a specific niche section for this.

It's not necessary for us to dedicate an entire section to this when there's already sections on the forum for it. You can ask for your server to be rated through the feedback forum.

Denied.

Thanks for your suggestion!