Rate this finished design?

[JumboGraphics]

Hello! I was wondering if you can rate this on a scale of 0/10.

Spoiler: Sketch After

Thanks for your opinion

 

[JumboGraphics]

The before image is broken.

Overall I'd say 9/10. My only complaint is the water bubble stuff is on the shark and octopus, would look better without it imo.

Thankyou!

 

[JumboGraphics]

The before image is broken.

Overall I'd say 9/10. My only complaint is the water bubble stuff is on the shark and octopus, would look better without it imo.

And the water on the shark and octopus is for that when they are out of the water they are wet

 

[Pose]

10/10 awesome designs!

 

[JumboGraphics]

Looks very cute! The octopus reminds me of Hank from Finding Dory.

Ha! Thats what its based on The owners nick name is Hank

 

[JumboGraphics]

7.5/10. The shading could be better.

Thankyou!

 

[jxhdvn]

10/10 Drawing
8/10 Shading can be better the octopus & shark out of water thing doesnt really work that well

 

[Eisenbahnn]

Looking very good.
But i think mascots shader are better than the font shader. You could improve the text certanly

9.0/10

 

[Picturesque]

10/10 nothing needs improvement!

 

[Grffin]

I would rate this at an 9/10, the design looks great, and I love the simplistic yet thorough style you utilized to give it that cartoon look. The only suggestion I have is to make the shading on the text more realistic to replace the gradients you are using right now.