Remove Trade rep

[StudioBeat]

Alright well to kick this off, its to easy to fake/gain fake rep with this thing. This is really the same thing as the " vouch " icon we used before, but with out the comments.

I for one is sick of this shit. A user ( 30760 ) left me a bad rep for saying he was on drugs because he wanted to sell a domain for $500, when clearly everyone knows its worth less than $10...
proof: http://www.mc-market.org/threads/82153/#post-968598
proof: https://gyazo.com/08f65915380d206a650f39de7fe955a0

My trade link to view his nasty comment on me: http://www.mc-market.org/trade/feedback/634/view

The same thing happened with TellingMom when someone left a bad feedback for something she never done..

These bad rep can really affect a person during trades, from people not trusting you.
Reason: We get put on this garbage list " Untrusted Traders " for something we never even done.

I think this needs to change....

 

[Synth]

Well, it used to be like that.

Good thing it's not anymore right? right..? right...... right........................

 

[Dobbs]

Agree!

 

[ShadyPaws]

They should add a option so like if you star them a 3 and under it asks the other person (Who it is being sent to) if its okay to post on their page

 

[Tyler]

Just report the bad reputation if you consider it unfair. A staff member will handle it eventually.

key word: eventually

 

[TellingMom]

key word: eventually

If they're going to keep this bad rep system, they should add a staffer to handle reports exclusively. Eventually is too long when reputation matters with making deals.

 

[kitcat]

Don't remove it, just moderate it. lmao.

 

[Tyler]

If they're going to keep this bad rep system, they should add a staffer to handle reports exclusively. Eventually is too long when reputation matters with making deals.

someone gave me negative feedback for retracting a bid, we never made a deal, he was mad. so i gave him negative feedback back, and i got a warning for it and his negative feedback was removed. I still have mine and my report has not been resolved I assume, so I have this negative point for nothing and it makes me look bad lol

 

[Magnemite]

Add a voting board! (forgot the name ;P)

 

[StudioBeat]

Mick Jack tjrgg thoughts?

 

[Tyler]

Maybe you shouldn't give someone negative feedback as an act of revenge. That is unjust.

Still, he was in the wrong and it still has not been removed

 

[Ivain]

The system is a good way of giving feedback about the user. I feel like the numbers are unnecessary though, since that reduces the quality back to the random vouch system we had before. The trade rep option should stay, but it should be mandatory to show what sort of deal you did with them.
as for the fake negative feedback, people have been asking for a second scam officer, and I feel like we should have one specifically for trade rep.[DOUBLEPOST=1457115306][/DOUBLEPOST]

Still, he was in the wrong and it still has not been removed

yeah, I feel like it was implemented before staff were ready to deal with the consequences.

 

[Tyler]

The system is a good way of giving feedback about the user. I feel like the numbers are unnecessary though, since that reduces the quality back to the random vouch system we had before. The trade rep option should stay, but it should be mandatory to show what sort of deal you did with them.
as for the fake negative feedback, people have been asking for a second scam officer, and I feel like we should have one specifically for trade rep.[DOUBLEPOST=1457115306][/DOUBLEPOST]
yeah, I feel like it was implemented before staff were ready to deal with the consequences.

They are never ready for anything they do, they always do stuff that they can't handle or the community doesn't like

 

[Ivain]

They are never ready for anything they do, they always do stuff that they can't handle or the community doesn't like

wouldn't say always, but it does happen a bit often.

 

[TellingMom]

Keep in mind guys, ebay (the largest online store/auction site has a feedback system just like ours. If it works for them, it will work for us!

To leave feedback on Ebay you HAVE to have verified transaction. You can't just randomly leave feedback for people. This system requires absolutely no deal. Also sellers on Ebay can not leave negative feedback, only positive.

I was frivolously given a negative feedback by some idiot who is now banned. I reported it several days ago, and it's still there. Unfortunately, this system is fail in it's current iteration.

 

[Synth]

To leave feedback on Ebay you HAVE to have verified transaction. You can't just randomly leave feedback for people. This system requires absolutely no deal. Also sellers on Ebay can not leave negative feedback, only positive.

I was frivolously given a negative feedback by some idiot who is now banned. I reported it several days ago, and it's still there. Unfortunately, this system is fail in it's current iteration.

Seems like they just need more active staff on it, not removing it entirely.