Reputation Disputes

Status
Jerry

Jerry

Confirm ONSITE
Supreme
Feedback score
73
Posts
1,250
Reactions
1,194
Resources
0
Two parts to this,

1) if a reputation rating is older than x amount, it can't be disputed but must be worked out between the users. It is impossible to keep a record of each negative rating a user has given and it doesn't make sense that a user can go back and just start disputing every negative rating they've received in hopes it will get removed because a user is inactive.

2) If a user opens a dispute and does not reply for x amount of time, the dispute is closed. Personal situation where a user read and didn't/hasn't replied in almost two months however @/eclipse just recently replied to the thread asking me for more proof after I've given sufficient evidence for the rating I posted.

The rep system is trash but this rep dispute system is even more trash.

If you disagree, reply with reasoning please.
 
Type
Suggestion
Status
Denied
Upvote 6 Downvote
PebbleHost
High performance, consistent uptime and fast support. Minecraft hosting that just works.
Sloth

Sloth

Feed Me
Supreme
Feedback score
6
Posts
4,370
Reactions
2,660
Resources
0
This thread isn’t even about the original suggestion, it’s about two people fighting over post farming and being mad at each other.
 
MTG

MTG

愛
Supreme
Feedback score
78
Posts
2,455
Reactions
2,600
Resources
0
Sloth said:
This thread isn’t even about the original suggestion, it’s about two people fighting over post farming and being mad at each other.
Click to expand...
ok sherlock
 
D

DeletedUser372845

Deactivated
Feedback score
13
Posts
677
Reactions
109
Resources
0
This just does not seem fair, if a member quited the market for a couple months, and can't remove that x reputation that he forgot to appeal before.
 
Jerry

Jerry

Confirm ONSITE
Supreme
Feedback score
73
Posts
1,250
Reactions
1,194
Resources
0
DiamondLunatic said:
This just does not seem fair, if a member quited the market for a couple months, and can't remove that x reputation that he forgot to appeal before.
Click to expand...
They can dispute the rating when it's applied.
 
Mick

Mick

BuiltByBit Owner
Management
Feedback score
28
Posts
6,412
Reactions
7,666
Resources
0
Jerry said:
1) if a reputation rating is older than x amount, it can't be disputed but must be worked out between the users. It is impossible to keep a record of each negative rating a user has given and it doesn't make sense that a user can go back and just start disputing every negative rating they've received in hopes it will get removed because a user is inactive.
Click to expand...
If a user provided all of the proof that they should've in the first place this wouldn't be a problem, especially now that we're no longer allowing our users to report legacy feedback.

Jerry said:
2) If a user opens a dispute and does not reply for x amount of time, the dispute is closed. Personal situation where a user read and didn't/hasn't replied in almost two months however @/eclipse just recently replied to the thread asking me for more proof after I've given sufficient evidence for the rating I posted.
Click to expand...
This is more of a problem if the staff member is busy with a lot of disputes and loses a dispute in their conversations. If someone doesn't respond and they need to respond to keep the dispute moving, then it would be closed. If that person isn't replying but also isn't needed at that moment because the other user needs to provide proof for it to be considered valid/invalid, then it doesn't really make a difference if the other user hasn't responded (thanks Kram).

In the future please create suggestions on their on thread each, as it is much easier for us to give feedback if they're separate.

Denied, thanks for the suggestion.
 
Status
Top