The removal of legacy feedback

Should legacy feedback be removed?

  • Yes

    Votes: 12 9.5%
  • No

    Votes: 113 89.7%
  • Indifferent

    Votes: 1 0.8%

  • Total voters
    126
Status
This thread has been locked.

K9

Filmmaker / Animator
Supreme
Feedback score
27
Posts
465
Reactions
684
Resources
0
Even for the current reputation system and how it’s also to, I guess... make sure the deals are legit and to tackle “rep4rep”/fake rep or any form of forgery alike... I don’t even see how that’s a suitable fix for it.

It doesn’t take an intellectual to add another step to forge screenshots of deals which are as easy as making a conversation and saying random bs. Oh, and if it takes extents like evidence of legitimate ownership of said acc(or service/product) through a deal, you’ll be surprised how far users would go to prove that, wether temp nfa, namemc Access, or the OP sending screenshots from his/her perspective in place for the “buyer’s proof of ownership”.

Why you would focus on removing legacy rep instead of this system is beyond me. But hey, even I have no idea how to fix it.
 

K9

Filmmaker / Animator
Supreme
Feedback score
27
Posts
465
Reactions
684
Resources
0
Yeah it's a pretty weird decision to make.

The recent reputation purge brought me from 331 down to 233, losing 98 rep.
After the 14th I'll lose 163 more rep, bringing me down to 70 rep.

I guess it'll make ban evading rep farmers seem more legit.
Especially for those reputable who just stopped dealing onsite as of late, it’s stupid that they’re now gonna be seen as untrusted due to dropping to single/low digits...
 

Jack

Retired Moderator
Supreme
Feedback score
11
Posts
1,209
Reactions
1,462
Resources
0
Problem: Butt-hurt users going around and reporting targeted users legacy reputation which does not have evidence attached.

(0 IQ) Solution: Remove all legacy reputation.

At least this is what Mick has outlined in his post.

(200 IQ) Solution: Lock reputation in after it is 1 week (1 month?) old. This will allow users to report reputation they have received which they deem is unfair/etc. If users have had rep that's several years old, why is it being removed?

Edit: Already lost 8 out of 19 rep. Will be down to 0 after the 14th?
 
Last edited:

ThaMango

Owner of Odyssey Builds
Ultimate
Feedback score
68
Posts
9
Reactions
483
Resources
0
This update is honestly a joke. Nobody wants it apart from the owners; as there's no need for it. The reputations given are all mostly valid regardless of if they follow the current rules - the format of them shouldn't matter.
 

Blaze.

Confirm on-site, or don't idrc.
Deactivated
Feedback score
51
Posts
991
Reactions
1,002
Resources
0

Sloth

Feed Me
Supreme
Feedback score
6
Posts
4,369
Reactions
2,660
Resources
0
Something that I just realized is imagine the users that are AFK that have a decent amount of reputation that return to the site to see all their reputation has been removed. Ouch.
 

Dad

MCMCon Entrepreneur
Supreme
Feedback score
62
Posts
2,404
Reactions
1,706
Resources
0
This site pushes me to disable a little more everyday.
Soon it'll be 100%.
 

Scroll32

Supreme
Feedback score
101
Posts
1,725
Reactions
421
Resources
0
I see a lot of scams happening until the 14th because people will be done after losing their rep in the future.
 

Lucian929

CEO of Hibiscuses
Premium
Feedback score
5
Posts
108
Reactions
47
Resources
4
This may not affect me, but this is fucking ridiculous. People are going to lose SO much reputation. Please, PLEASE don't do this. You guys are killing MCM.
 

Overtime

Not Member
Premium
Feedback score
17
Posts
646
Reactions
238
Resources
0
This is stupid
 

Aekalix

Terraforming Connoisseur
Premium
Feedback score
46
Posts
1,725
Reactions
1,264
Resources
0
Since rep changes I've lost roughly 40 rep and it will drop further.[DOUBLEPOST=1575135882][/DOUBLEPOST]
Keeping the Minecraft account section? "We disagree, but the majority of our community wants it, so we will keep them."

Not removing rep which disproportionately affects older members? "Justis wants it, the majority of the community doesn't, even most staff members, but nah, it's getting removed anyway."
The Minecraft account section generates money, that's the only reason why they are keeping it.
 
Last edited:

K9

Filmmaker / Animator
Supreme
Feedback score
27
Posts
465
Reactions
684
Resources
0
Keeping the Minecraft account section? "We disagree, but the majority of our community wants it, so we will keep them."

Not removing rep which disproportionately affects older members? "Justis wants it, the majority of the community doesn't, even most staff members, but nah, it's getting removed anyway."
lmao, first they piss off the OG com with the Minecraft selly section, now they piss of the whole damn site with the rep system. Outstanding move
 

Lyfe

Supreme
Feedback score
37
Posts
983
Reactions
417
Resources
0
Damn, I came back to MCM after leaving for half a year and I'm greeted with this bullshit?
 

BOOP

Director of Ops @ Zelphra
Supreme
Feedback score
23
Posts
2,384
Reactions
1,095
Resources
0
Damn, I came back to MCM after leaving for half a year and I'm greeted with this bullshit?
You sure do! Happy welcoming back, hope you enjoy your gift straight from the MCM administration!
 
Status
This thread has been locked.
Top