Just need you guy's opinion on my edits here is the link to my most proudest one:
~
Thanks
~
Thanks
Video Editor needing Feedback
- Thread starter Dezpwcible
- Start date
- Status
PebbleHost
High performance, consistent uptime and fast support. Minecraft hosting that just works.
well isnt that the point of mc edits these days lmao Blur+2xBlur+weird effect +999999xBlur = views lol
ON GOD you havent seen what I've seen out here....[DOUBLEPOST=1514748629][/DOUBLEPOST]
i dont think im ready to teach...just tell me what i should improve[DOUBLEPOST=1514748745][/DOUBLEPOST]It's good I like that.
Maybe, teach me?
8/10
so you mean more combos?
Last edited:
This definitely isn't 1080p, I would check the settings you export to first.
I understand most of these montage edit videos are going for that "high impact, trap soundtrack" thing, and that's fine, but I think more effort needs to be put in meaningful edits. Making the camera shake and zoom and pull back for no particular reason doesn't really do anything to hype you. Like maybe add different cuts to different opponents every time you kill one, something more interesting to look at maybe. Minecraft fighting is already hard to follow (atleast for me) so adding all these effects that don't convey any meaning just makes it unwatchable to someone like me.
I'd say MECHANICALLY other than the resolution, the effects are fine. The zooms at the end at ~0:18 and 0:20 that are really linear and take too many frames and zoom out/in too much, but that's a bit of a nitpick. I think it could be really great provided you know what you're supposed to be recording, as I'm assuming this is just a test for your editing skills.
I understand most of these montage edit videos are going for that "high impact, trap soundtrack" thing, and that's fine, but I think more effort needs to be put in meaningful edits. Making the camera shake and zoom and pull back for no particular reason doesn't really do anything to hype you. Like maybe add different cuts to different opponents every time you kill one, something more interesting to look at maybe. Minecraft fighting is already hard to follow (atleast for me) so adding all these effects that don't convey any meaning just makes it unwatchable to someone like me.
I'd say MECHANICALLY other than the resolution, the effects are fine. The zooms at the end at ~0:18 and 0:20 that are really linear and take too many frames and zoom out/in too much, but that's a bit of a nitpick. I think it could be really great provided you know what you're supposed to be recording, as I'm assuming this is just a test for your editing skills.
Last edited:
T H A N K YOU from the bottom of my heart...ive never received such meaningful feedback. As for the quality i rendered the video twice first time was the actual video and second time was to add the black cinematic bars which i think is very crucial for most edits,but the video was originally recorded in 1366x768 and 120fps so i particular think rendering it in 1080p would be the best choice but i could render it in 720p so i would like your feedback on that. As for the style of editing i do i really try to put a story behind them for example if a relative passed away and i feel like dying i would do an edit but other than that ill try to make more "meaningful" edits. But at the end of the day im only doing this so i can test my editing skills as i aim to become a professional editor. Thank you for your time.
Definitely try rendering in 720p as you need to record the footage at a minimum of 1080 vertical resolution at 16:9 ratio to export to 1080p. Also, you should only have to render your video once. Look up on YouTube how to add cinematic bars. If you use Vegas, it's as simple as using the pan/crop tool.
And yeah, I completely understand that since this is a test then it won't have the most meaningful footage to use and that's fine. Good luck man, looking good.
pvp part was pretty good for me, but there was such an abrupt ending. try to smooth it out. Also, in those cinematic clips, it looked to me at first that you were lagging + they weren't smooth. fix those things and itll be a lot better
- Status
