Add a highest reputation list in Members

[Choo]

I think it would be cool and simple to add a list of the most reputable members on MC-Market.

Here is where the button will be located: https://gyazo.com/5935c6706178d48760d6612ee1afa1ef

That way it would be easier to find the most reputable members on the market. System will work the same as it works right now, if someone has 140 positive rep and 0 negative rep than he will count as 140. Another person who has 143 positive rep but 4 negative rep will be placed below the first person with 139 positive rep.

Leave your thoughts below.

 

[Ivain]

What Wynos is saying nicely illustrates my point.
Reputation gained by reselling something, or selling one thing many times, is not NEARLY as valuable as reputation gained by selling a creation, selling something very valuable like an OG account successfully or making something custom on a request.

If I had gained all of my rep just with my non-exclusive build shop, it would be practically worthless in comparison to how it is now.

So, to reiterate again, I don't think something that gives people the illusion that reputation quantity matters past a certain point should be implemented. It would be a step backwards.

And honestly, I wouldn't mind if the 'most posts' etc stuff got removed as well, I just know that at least some members would be tempted to commit murder if that happened.

 

[Choo]

What Wynos is saying nicely illustrates my point.
Reputation gained by reselling something, or selling one thing many times, is not NEARLY as valuable as reputation gained by selling a creation, selling something very valuable like an OG account successfully or making something custom on a request.

If I had gained all of my rep just with my non-exclusive build shop, it would be practically worthless in comparison to how it is now.

So, to reiterate again, I don't think something that gives people the illusion that reputation quantity matters past a certain point should be implemented. It would be a step backwards.

And honestly, I wouldn't mind if the 'most posts' etc stuff got removed as well, I just know that at least some members would be tempted to commit murder if that happened.

You'd be one of those people to take this new section too seriously and do what I think is "criticize their reputation". This isn't really made to assume who's the most reputable person on the platform by numbers, rather have a reason like what Reaper and Sam said. But yes, it will show their numbers, and like me and you agree to disagree, numbers don't mean everything.
As said before, the situation with the "most posts" or the most everything on that section of this forum is all partially lies, lots of people on there were once post boosting their way to the top or whatever they needed to do to get on those leaderboards.

 

[Aeris]

I personally don't think something this would be viewed often for any specific purpose. For this reason, I can't seeing it do much worse than it could do good. Not particularly worth adding.

 

[Kaito]

Plain and simple: this isn't necessary.

AdamEdits Explain why you disagreed, thanks.

 

[Mick]

Why though? What would getting something custom for this actually achieve? It just seems like we'd be making a change for the sake of making it and it isn't really necessary.

There are so many things that need to be done and adding something cosmetic like this.

Denied, thanks for the suggestion.