Remove total Ratings or REVAMP, Keep post ratings

Status

Corey B

MGR || ClusterWorks LLC
Banned
Feedback score
0
Posts
711
Reactions
612
Resources
0
Ratings are the downfall to everything. We all know this. The people that say "my ratings are what makes my rep" are complete idiots. Let's go over the reasons:

- Most scams = People with REP or Alts with no Rep. People that believe building rep will make them seem trustworthy is completely wrong. People have scammed in all sorts of ways, little or big rep. The people that usually scam are high rep because on your post they think more ratings would mean more trust. The people that scam know this thought process and think "That's how I will scam"

- There isn't competition. The people with high ratings will be more trusted then people with low ratings because they think a system can tell them who is and isn't trust worthy. This kind of thinking needs to go away because I don't trust users high ratings or low. I go off of my own system that has worked in the past.

Point is. You all say ratings build rep, show you're trustworthy,etc. But you're dumb if you think that a number system that is abused every single day, can say if you can be trusted or if you will scam. No one knows that. Not even you.


Post below your thoughts and opinions. Poll will be added if requested.

~Side Note: I didn't add a poll because it takes 2 seconds for someone to come here who doesn't know anything or doesn't care, and hits the button everyone else does. IF you care, you will speak your reason and debate it.
 
Type
Suggestion
Status
Denied
Last edited:
Banned forever. Reason: Attempting scam setup. https://builtbybit.com/threads/goodbye(corey-b.93488/)
PebbleHost
High performance, consistent uptime and fast support. Minecraft hosting that just works.

Chearful

thomas.gg
Supreme
Feedback score
115
Posts
1,398
Reactions
2,236
Resources
0
-1.

When they were temporarily removed earlier, everyone in SB went fucking crazy about it.
 

Corey B

MGR || ClusterWorks LLC
Banned
Feedback score
0
Posts
711
Reactions
612
Resources
0
-1.

When they were temporarily removed earlier, everyone in SB went fucking crazy about it.

That's because it was at random. They weren't going crazy because it was removed, it was out of surprise and the only reaction was to be ballistic.
 
Banned forever. Reason: Attempting scam setup. https://builtbybit.com/threads/goodbye(corey-b.93488/)

Chearful

thomas.gg
Supreme
Feedback score
115
Posts
1,398
Reactions
2,236
Resources
0
That's because it was at random. They weren't going crazy because it was removed, it was out of surprise and the only reaction was to be ballistic.
Well on another post to hide them, it received 56 downvotes, lol
 

Corey B

MGR || ClusterWorks LLC
Banned
Feedback score
0
Posts
711
Reactions
612
Resources
0
Well on another post to hide them, it received 56 downvotes, lol

Link me?

Also, half those people will probably scam once they are finished with this site. Just need those higher ratings to get the trust to do it. See how ratings become an issue?
 
Banned forever. Reason: Attempting scam setup. https://builtbybit.com/threads/goodbye(corey-b.93488/)

Chearful

thomas.gg
Supreme
Feedback score
115
Posts
1,398
Reactions
2,236
Resources
0

BuildNIX

Supreme
Feedback score
4
Posts
114
Reactions
113
Resources
0
Remove it! Vouch for removal, Willing to pay!
 

Latouth

Troubled on Linux? Ask me!
Supreme
Feedback score
18
Posts
1,213
Reactions
504
Resources
0
Ratings are the downfall to everything. We all know this. The people that say "my ratings are what makes my rep" are complete idiots. Let's go over the reasons:

- Most scams = High rep. People that believe building rep will make them seem trustworthy is completely wrong. People have scammed in all sorts of ways, little or big rep. The people that usually scam are high rep because on your post they think more ratings would mean more trust. The people that scam know this thought process and think "That's how I will scam"

- There isn't competition. The people with high ratings will be more trusted then people with low ratings because they think a system can tell them who is and isn't trust worthy. This kind of thinking needs to go away because I don't trust users high ratings or low. I go off of my own system that has worked in the past.

Point is. You all say ratings build rep, show you're trustworthy,etc. But you're dumb if you think that a number system that is abused every single day, can say if you can be trusted or if you will scam. No one knows that. Not even you.


Post below your thoughts and opinions. Poll will be added if requested.

~Side Note: I didn't add a poll because it takes 2 seconds for someone to come here who doesn't know anything or doesn't care, and hits the button everyone else does. IF you care, you will speak your reason and debate it.
Oh, high rep doesn't mean they won't scam?
Ok mr. 402 rep scammer
 

Corey B

MGR || ClusterWorks LLC
Banned
Feedback score
0
Posts
711
Reactions
612
Resources
0
Oh, high rep doesn't mean they won't scam?
Ok mr. 402 rep scammer

People have called me scammers, Nara has posted jokes about me to make me look bad. Hasn't changed anything as I am still trusted.

-10000
No thanks, don't support this cause. leave it the way it is and has been for years now, why change? for your own personal desire? or is it just so you can be one of the only ones trying to get rid of the ratings system, it gives us dealers a rough estimate with who we're dealing with, if they have 120 messages but 3 ratings then we know not to deal with them.

You say no and that it gives personal desire. I dont care what the ratings say, and neither should you . Anyone can rate something at random and you think "he must be trustworthy".

You say it gives dealers an estimate but ironically the ones you trust with high ratings scam anyways. You are just proving my point.
 
Banned forever. Reason: Attempting scam setup. https://builtbybit.com/threads/goodbye(corey-b.93488/)

BuildNIX

Supreme
Feedback score
4
Posts
114
Reactions
113
Resources
0
People have called me scammers, Nara has posted jokes about me to make me look bad. Hasn't changed anything as I am still trusted.



You say no and that it gives personal desire. I dont care what the ratings say, and neither should you . Anyone can rate something at random and you think "he must be trustworthy".

You say it gives dealers an estimate but ironically the ones you trust with high ratings scam anyways. You are just proving my point haha.
Agree.
 

Latouth

Troubled on Linux? Ask me!
Supreme
Feedback score
18
Posts
1,213
Reactions
504
Resources
0
People have called me scammers, Nara has posted jokes about me to make me look bad. Hasn't changed anything as I am still trusted.



You say no and that it gives personal desire. I dont care what the ratings say, and neither should you . Anyone can rate something at random and you think "he must be trustworthy".

You say it gives dealers an estimate but ironically the ones you trust with high ratings scam anyways. You are just proving my point.
It's just a joke.
Since rep doesn't mean trusted or not.
 

Corey B

MGR || ClusterWorks LLC
Banned
Feedback score
0
Posts
711
Reactions
612
Resources
0
The way I see it is,

The feedback rating system is better than the one me currently have, at least the majority of people with higher ratings won't be scamming, they will be doing fair trades, for most people it IS a good system to know who the more trustworthy sellers are due to experience on the site, people can read vouches too.

I don't think the problem is the feedback system, it's the community, and being the largest minecraft marketplace it's a lot easier for scammers to come and go as they please as there's a lot of people on this site (more people to scam). However the attitude of the people round here doesn't reflect helpfulness so that doesn't help, but maybe that's the factor of a lot of scammers just naturally coming here, either way this rating system is at least a little better than the current one, things like threads can be linked for more proof, as of now we should tell users to be more investigative of the people they're doing business with.

You obviously haven't been here the last 6 hours to see the abuse of the new "rep" system. It's complete trash like ratings. It won't solve anything. I say remove it.
 
Banned forever. Reason: Attempting scam setup. https://builtbybit.com/threads/goodbye(corey-b.93488/)

Corey B

MGR || ClusterWorks LLC
Banned
Feedback score
0
Posts
711
Reactions
612
Resources
0

I feel it's bias from people with higher ratings. Here I am with an average amount and requesting this. You don't want your ratings gone because you have a high amount. Monty and Nara complained because they had a high amount. The people that fought it the most seem like high rated users. That's why there isn't a poll.
 
Banned forever. Reason: Attempting scam setup. https://builtbybit.com/threads/goodbye(corey-b.93488/)
Status
Top