Reputation System

[Vice]

My reps get removed, even though most if not all have done a deal with me.

And thats not even a requirement for reputation, the requirement is to simply state your opinion.

Mick posting rep for others: https://gyazo.com/94f2ec49d1669e84f731db2787a8f344
Really, "can confirm he is cool". So that is a valid one but the nearly 20 reputation of mine you have removed is not valid?

Countless other people you constantly purge reputation of. Just because you created a shitty system doesn't mean you abuse to "fix" it. Reputations and ONLY positive ones are being removed in bulk from people. Though when it comes to any negative, they might be quick enough to remove a false one in say 2 weeks? Oh last time I brought this up to Mick, he did not acknowledge it. He merely said you will be notified next time. 20 rep down later and no notifications. Including 4 that were removed today. People act in such childish manners when it comes to negative rep, hell even I get butthurt when I get one. Thats the nature of everyone here. You're only adding venom to the bite everyone has been struck by. The actions arent going by unnoticed and shows a great lack of integrity on the staff team of this market.

Even better, when I brought it up in a support request like normal users should. It was ignored , then closed without a reply.
https://gyazo.com/1e3a1231f761ef9bb715d95e5ead6e10



Remove the system completely or actually think of reasonable fixes.

EDIT: Staff have locked my account at 71 positive reputation. I am not allowed to have more.

I was at 74/75 before this thread. I am now at 71. Lets see how low it goes.
Went from 70 to 64.
Went from 67 to 63.
Went back up to 72, the removed it down to 71.
Went back up to 72 AGAIN, the removed it down to 71.
Went back up to 73, then AGAIN it was removed down to 71.

 

[Ghast]

Who is the system admin for MCM?[DOUBLEPOST=1501242951][/DOUBLEPOST]Non related... but he's doing a shit job. Wonder if he's getting paid lmao[DOUBLEPOST=1501243099][/DOUBLEPOST]View attachment 74585
Well Justis read it...

I love how my name is right at the bottom.

 

[Vice]

74 Agrees. I believe a great amount of people also want this fixed.

 

[Kuno]

I agree with this, I got falsely repped by a member but he got banned

 

[Inverting]

What do you mean, you have your rep?

 

[Vice]

80 agrees. Thats some type of record and still not one staff member would love to comment.

 

[SuperCoolMomo]

80 agrees. Thats some type of record and still not one staff member would love to comment.

I feel like staff avoid the thread Mick Doge Shattered

 

[ZACK]

I agree, however by removing rep could ruin buisness for people.

New people arent going to know who to buy from etc, and people with 20 rep such as myself arent too known.

Maybe just make it more fair, as you said.

 

[Vice]

I was at 74/75 before this thread. I am now at 71. Lets see how low it goes.
Went back up to 72, the removed it down to 71.
Went back up to 72 AGAIN, the removed it down to 71.
Went back up to 73, then AGAIN it was removed down to 71.

And we are rolling with this. They seem to be ignoring this and many, I mean many people agree with what I have said. Everyone is experiencing this and staff are saying nothing.

Edit: July 20th posted: https://gyazo.com/1d33a3f2d3430ec5edc0005f8ac674aa Not one response. Transition from many different staff members too until it hit Mick. 18 views from staff members alone, I think we all know they have seen it more than enough.

 

[Vice]

Micks response to the abusive removal of everyone's hard earned positive reputations: https://gyazo.com/9d43dd56cbfdbf86551e0d2a20ee975c

Was not much of an answer really, more of a deflection.

Edit: This is an actual reply from a staff member since July 20th, 2017. Swell.

 

[utaninja]

Vice: Really, "Mick: can confirm utaninja is a cool dude". So that is a valid one but the nearly 20 reputation of mine you have removed is not valid?

The reputation he gave me was for a good reason. Even though it could have been written better.

 

[Aekalix]

A lot of staff have shitty reputations too. But they don't remove their own even if it breaks the rules, they do remove yours.

When is the official response coming?
When the Owner of the site abuses the reputation system too, then it's probably just hopeless.

Honestly, there isn't a good fix for the system. Because staff don't want to put in the effort to fix it or keep it from being abused.

 

[Mick]

Vice, if your reputation is being removed it will be for a reason. Your suggestion doesn't suggest anything other than removing the system (which there is already a suggestion for) and for the system to "be better", which helps nothing.

A lot of staff have shitty reputations too. But they don't remove their own even if it breaks the rules, they do remove yours.

When is the official response coming?
When the Owner of the site abuses the reputation system too, then it's probably just hopeless.

Honestly, there isn't a good fix for the system. Because staff don't want to put in the effort to fix it or keep it from being abused.

If you feel that any reputation breaks the rules you can report it. Me owning the site has no influence on my reputation. I probably would have a better reputation if I didn't run the site since I wouldn't be making difficult decisions the whole time.

Vice: Really, "Mick: can confirm utaninja is a cool dude". So that is a valid one but the nearly 20 reputation of mine you have removed is not valid?

The reputation he gave me was for a good reason. Even though it could have been written better.

Even still from what I can see, that reputation has never been reported. Vice seems to like complaining and calling abuse and takes no attempt to report the content.

A suggestion to make the system "better" achieves nothing, clogs up the forum, and wastes time.
Denied.